The ‘double-live’ often used to be the high water mark of a rock band’s career. Think back to your vinyl collection. Chances are the most dog-eared items were
Made In Japan, Strangers In the Night, maybe
MSG’s One Night At Budokan, but most definitely
Live and Dangerous. Many artists suddenly found their stumbling career path shooting off into the stratosphere on the back of a live album –
Frampton Comes Alive is probably the most extreme example. Occasionally single disc live albums would make an impact;
Priest’s Unleashed In The East is a prime example; but in the hearts of rock fans of a certain age the double live is king.
All that was in the genre’s heyday of the 70’s and early 80’s. Since then live albums seem to have suffered a progressive decline in popularity. Perhaps the death of vinyl also presaged the demise of the live album. There was undoubtedly something magical about double gatefold sleeves, usually smothered in live shots that was more than a little reminiscent of a concert programme. CD sized booklets were never going to capture this. Improvements in studio production techniques have also had an impact. Many studio albums of the time failed to capture the essential power of a band that was abundantly evident on stage. Live albums somehow, possibly accidentally, overcame this problem and hence became the definitive recorded version –
Live & Dangerous illustrating this perfectly.
For whatever reason, live albums no longer seem to hold the position of eminence they once did – which makes the recent batch of issues reviewed below all the more interesting.
Live From Nowhere In Particular – Joe Bonamassa

The perfect example of how the live environment can lift an already impressive catalogue on to a higher plane. Wunderkind
Bonamassa has been pedalling his own particular brand of the blues for some time now but it’s on this epic double-live album that the boy becomes a man. His mastery of the blues guitar is beyond question and is showcased superbly on a collection of songs that spans the full range of electric-blues but the surprise here is that it is his breathless voice which really catches the attention. No longer a case of shut-up-and-play-your-guitar, the vocals are delivered with a passion and soulfulness that belies his relative youthfulness. The album is not without issues - extended work outs on
Woke up Dreaming and
Django/Just Got Paid are both over-long and over-indulgent (although snatches of
Dazed & Confused in
Just Got Paid does draw back your attention somewhat), but taken as a whole there is a real sense of occasion about this album – exactly what a live album is supposed to invoke.
Rating: Superior
Live in GdaÅ„sk – David Gilmour

One of the greatest rock guitarists of all time captured live in the shipyard where
Lech Wałęsa founded
Solidarność in 1980 and kick started the fall of the Soviet Union. This was the last night of
Gilmour’s On An Island tour and the last full-concert appearance for the late
Richard Wright.
After a fairly low-key opening salvo of
Dark Side of the Moon excerpts,
Gilmour’s On An Island album is played in full, one track after another, with only a slight change in running order to freshen things up. As on the original studio album this is a perfectly pleasant collection of tunes but one that is really only brought to life when
Gilmour’s magical guitar kicks-in. Whilst I am genuinely pleased that David has managed to find such happiness in family life, tales of domestic bliss rarely make for great rock music. Frankly I’m surprised that the
GdaÅ„sk crowd managed to stay awake until ‘Happy’ Gilmour stopped twiddling about and broke into
Shine on You Crazy Diamond. Thankfully that’s when things start to warm up and those in the Polish crowd who didn’t wander off for some chÅ‚odnik were rewarded for their patience.
Floyd’s ode to
Syd Barrett ups the ante exponentially on what has come before and the improvement continues apace for the rest of the set. Comprised completely of Floyd classics of various vintage it includes the positively neolithic
Astronomy Domine &
Fat Old Sun, the rarely (if ever) aired
A Great Day for Freedom and the definitely never played live (by Floyd anyway)
Wot's... Uh The Deal? from
Obscured By Clouds. Such rarities are very welcome but there is a lingering disappointment that
Gilmour didn’t manage to include some tracks from his other (at times excellent) solo work in favour of the slightly flaky
On An Island material.
The undoubted highlight of the set is a spine-chilling version of
Echoes showcasing
Richard Wright heavily.
Gilmour and his band apply themselves fully to a song that is now an incredible 37 years old and serve up over 25 minutes of sheer prog bliss that even manages to eclipse set closer
Comfortably Numb.Ultimately the gap in quality between
Gilmour’s solo work/post-Waters Floyd work and that from when
Pink Floyd were still a band is fully exposed on
Live In Gdańsk - clearly illustrating that Floyd were always greater than the sum of their parts. Having said that,
Gilmour’s guitar playing remains as awe-inspiring as ever and in the absence of a full Floyd reunion this is as close things are going to get – if you skip straight from track 4 to track 15 that is.
Rating: Superior
Thin Lizzy – UK Tour ‘75
Live & Dangerous is generally accepted as the greatest live album of all-time. I still believe this to be true despite all the rumour and counter-rumours of studio overdubbing that have circulated over the years. No matter how much of that album was recorded in the studio the fact remains that it captures perfectly one of the best ever live bands at the height of their powers and does so better than any of their purely studio albums ever did.
What makes
UK ’75 so interesting is that it is an entirely ‘raw’ radio recording of a one night stand. 100% guaranteed no overdubs. The question that raises is … why on earth would
Lizzy feel the need to allegedly re-record so much of
Live & Dangerous when they were this tight live? Yes – there are mistakes but very few of them, and those that there are generally help in serving up the live atmosphere to even greater effect. The twin guitar attack roars,
Downey’s drumming is immaculate and
Lynott’s vocals are usually pristine.
The opening half of the set features a selection of criminally overlooked tracks from the
Nightlife and
Fighting albums (ironically they are probably overlooked because they didn’t feature on
Live & Dangerous).
Fighting My Way Back , It's Only Money , Wild One, For Those Who Love To Live & Showdown sound all the better for their relative lack of familiarity. The remainder of the album collects live staples that featured on
L&D and remained a part of the
Lizzy set until the very end.
Suicide, Rosalie, The Rocker, Sha La La, Me And The Boys and (“our National Anthem”)
Baby Drives Me Crazy roar with the unbridled power of a band straining every sinew to break into the big-time. Add an early prototype version of
The Cowboy Song, the rarely heard
Little Darling and a fascinating
Sound Check Jam into the mix and what comes out is 78 minutes of raw-edged brilliance that is often (adopts hushed whisper) even better than
Live & Dangerous!
Rating: Essential